All reports

Playing Poker at the Dairy Desk

10 min read
  • Butter
  • Cheese
  • Powder
  • Liquids

Last week was a fun week to watch the market from the sidelines. With increasing activity in our cheese book, we’re happy and proud to see more partners giving their trust to Joey and our team. The powder market found a bit of upward momentum, and on butter we continue to grind lower. Even yesterday the market started with some activity, pushing powder prices slightly up and pressing butter prices further down, while on cheese we continue to trade the curve flat.

I am not a betting man myself; otherwise I would have stayed a trader ;) But in my student days, there was nothing I loved watching on TV more than a good game of poker. Having played it a couple of times myself, I noticed there’s a big difference between making every right decision from the couch with nothing on the line, and actually being caught with a good hand against a bluffing bully. And the more I look at this dairy market, the more it feels like I’m back in my student room at 02:30, watching a guy called Daniel beat a full house, aces over kings, with four of a kind.

Before everyone starts sending us angry emails saying trading is something completely different from gambling: we agree! But ask a seasoned poker player and he’ll tell you the same thing. Playing poker isn’t just hoping to have better cards than your opponent. It’s also weighing every option the deck can give you, and reading the rest of the table. Just like in poker, you need to be aware that you’re only seeing your own cards, and the market can deal some pretty strange flops and even nastier river cards. So how would we identify our dairy market partners?

Butter Market: All In with Aces

In the butter market, it feels like we’re watching buyers on a winning streak being dealt the strongest possible starting hand in poker: pocket aces. On a roll and having won most of the hands over the last months, buyers are confident this hand has almost zero chance of turning into a losing one. Over the last few weeks alone, the butter market traded down. We saw a weaker GDT for fats, and since then SGX futures have kept falling. CME futures traded further down as the latest USDA production report showed the US produced yet another record month of butter. And that’s all just outside Europe.

Within Europe, cream levels are starting to slide, and that’s in early November, when we would have expected cream to stay elevated for at least another week or two. Now that quotations are coming down a bit, the full curve is slowly losing momentum. We have traded butter for November/December at €3,550 FCA NL, January at €3,600 and Q1 at €3,675. Further out, we’ve seen trades for Q1+Q2+Q3 at €3,950 and H1 at €3,850. All of these prices point towards lower and lower levels. Our buyers seem confident their pocket aces are about to bring them a good payout.

Still, watching from the sidelines, this hand has become fun to watch. The flop (the first three cards the dealer lays out after the first round of betting) has dealt the sellers something that doesn’t leave them completely without a chance. We struggle to figure out how strong their hand really is, but they have called the buyers’ bet and want to see the next cards. A bit less milk in the UK and France, strong export numbers: they might be small positive indicators, but the sellers aren’t drawing dead. If the turn and the river turn out to be good cards, could the sellers still come out on top?

From the sidelines, it’s easy to call this market. If we were buyers, we’d go all in. There are maybe two or three cards left in the deck that could turn this market more bullish. Yet that’s where a bad poker player like ourselves differs from a good one (like most traders). Even when the chances are small, we see traders hesitating to go all in, or simply checking towards the river. They like their chances of holding the winning hand, but they’re wise enough to know that even pocket aces can lose to a 7-2 offsuit.

Where does that leave the table? Our forward curve currently looks roughly like this:

USLBNL/DE/BE bidNL/DE/BE offerIrish bidIrish offer
December€3,550€3,600€3,500€3,600
Q1 2027€3,700€3,800€3,600€3,700
Q2 2027€3,850€3,950€3,750€3,850
Q3 2027€4,050€4,150€3,950€4,050

NL/DE/BE: if fresh max 30 days, if frozen max 6 months old.

Powder Market: Three of a Kind

Looking at the powder market, the sellers have been on the winning side, though they’ve played some stressful hands along the way. We’d say SMP sellers have been dealt almost as strong hands as the butter buyers, yet they’ve faced some nerve-wracking flops, turns and rivers. We’ve even seen SMP sellers fold strong, winning hands, because the cards on the table gave the buyers plenty of outs.

Look at milk production worldwide: it remains very strong, and you’d think that keeps powder production up as well. But look at the data again: more milk doesn’t mean more SMP (or NFDM). The same USDA report that showed record butter production for September also showed the lowest US NFDM/SMP production in 48 months. In the EU, up-to-date data is harder to find, but one of our leading indicators remains Germany. Over the last few weeks, German milk deliveries have been flat on last year. Yet over those same weeks, SMP production has kept falling by around 20% year on year.

We see those numbers reflected in slightly higher trades over the past days. Non-standardised product traded at €3,750, Ukrainian product at €3,650, and codex right in between at € 3700 / € 3725. The market isn’t hitting new highs every day, but it’s certainly not trading down. But the powder sellers are less aggressive poker players than butter buyers. At higher levels, we find it easier to find sellers cashing in a good hand than buyers willing to call or raise.

The numbers tell a story. Milk is growing in the US and flat in Germany, yet SMP/NFDM production is falling while butter production stays stable to increasing. That tells you something about where the milk is flowing. Less is going to powder. Where is it going instead? That’s a hard guess, and maybe the cheese table holds part of the answer. But with demand increasing and production not following, the supply/demand balance in SMP is shifting in the sellers’ favour quickly. Very quickly.

At the poker table, the sellers are holding three of a kind. They like their chances, but three of a kind can be beaten. Watching from the sidelines, we’d fancy a bet here if we were a buyer and we were buying some stock, and we like the sellers’ odds of prices increasing. But with plenty of uncertainty still on the table, we’ve seen the sellers check the flop, and we expect them to keep checking on the turn and the river unless they hit a full house or four of a kind.

Unlike the butter table, nobody here is in a hurry to show their cards.

Our starting offers:

VolumePeriodProductSpecificationPackingPriceTerms
300 mtNovIrish SMP MHmin. 37% as-is, May 2026BB/25kg bags€3,850DAP NL
200 mtNovA-ware SMP MH (codex)fresh, incl. export docs25kg bags€3,790FCA BE
100 mtPromptUnst SMP Łowiczfresh, min. 34% protein as-is–€3,740FCA PL
100 mtPromptPolish D40, Ostrowia originfresh25kg bags€1,720FCA PL
88 mtNov/DecLacPatrick SMP MHfresh25kg bags€3,800FCA N-IE
66 mtNovReny Picot SMP MHfresh25kg bags€3,700FCA NL
60 mtPromptPolish Unst SMP MHmin. 36.3% as-is, May 2026–€3,760FCA PL
50 mtNovLactalis WPC35, Italian originmax. 3 months old25kg bags€4,550FCA IT
50 mtNovPolish SWP Rykimax. 3 months old25kg bags€1,950FCA PL
25 mtPromptPolish SWP Skierniewicemax. 3 months old–€2,000FCA PL
25 mtPromptPolish BMPmax. 3 months old25kg bags€3,460FCA PL

Cheese Market: Checking and Letting Fate Decide

The cheese poker players are sitting at a different table altogether. The players here seem to fancy a drink and a chat with their opponents, and they keep glancing at the other tables, where their colleagues are playing big hands. While the action sits at those other tables, most of our cheese partners just check their hands to the end and let fate decide.

We struggle to find any line in the cheese game. Every time it feels like the best hands are dealt to the buyers, the flop favours the sellers, the turn makes both hands equally strong, and the river decides the winner. Over the past weeks, we’d say cheese sellers have held the winning hands, but we don’t really fancy their chances going forward. With Gouda prices leading towards € 3650-€3700 and Mozzarella spot trades even slightly higher we have seen prices on this years highs. 

More milk, more production capacity, still relatively high prices for whey products (yes, we know WPC80 has taken a beating) and a very competitive export market keep our expectations for higher prices on the forward curve small. Yet on the spot market, we see less mozzarella, less edam, less emmental and less gouda available. That’s a clear bullish sign.

Being a cheese seller in this market is like being dealt a pair of tens. It’s not the worst hand, but plenty of hands can beat it. With a jack on the flop, it feels like the entire cheese market is checking all the way to the end again. And if you zoom out, low volatility in cheese keeps participants from regretting decisions they made earlier.

We expect our market to open as follows:

ProductPeriodOrigin / specTermsBidOfferVolume
Cagliata 45%NovTirlanEXW–€3,50022 mt
Edam 30+NovEstonian origin, 15kgFCA EE–€3,35022 mt
GoudaNovNL/DEFCA€3,650–22 mt
GoudaNovNLFCA NL–€3,70022 mt
Gouda Frau AntjeNovNL/DEFCA–€3,70022 mt
MozzarellaNovNL/DEFCA€3,700–22 mt
Mozzarella (frozen)NovDE, freshly frozenEXW PL–€3,70022 mt
Cheddar curdDecIRL/EUEXW–€3,95022 mt
EdamDecNL/DEEXW–€3,60022 mt
EdamDecSE, fresh, 10kgEXW NL–€3,35022 mt
GoudaDecNL/DEEXW–€3,65066 mt
Gouda Frau AntjeDecNL/DEFCA–€3,70022 mt
MozzarellaDecNL/DE/BEFCA–€3,70022 mt
Cheddar curdJan 2027Island of IrelandEXW–€3,97522 mt
MozzarellaJan 2027NL/DE/BEFCA–€3,75022 mt
MozzarellaJan 2027DEEXW–€3,65020 mt
Cheddar curdQ1 2027UK/EUFCA€3,700–66 mt
GoudaQ1 2027NL/DEFCA–€3,70066 mt
Gouda Frau AntjeQ1 2027NLFCA–€3,76066 mt
MozzarellaQ1 2027NL/DE/BEFCA€3,550€3,75066 mt
MozzarellaQ2 2027NL/DE/BEFCA–€3,85066 mt

Final Note: It’s a Tournament, Not a Hand

Back to my student room one last time. The guy holding the full house, aces over kings, did nothing wrong that night. He played a great hand, and Daniel’s four of a kind still took the pot. That’s poker, and that’s markets. The players who make it to the final table aren’t the ones who win every hand. They’re the ones who can lose a hand like that and still have chips left for the next one.

Look at the tables this week. Butter buyers are holding aces, powder sellers have three of a kind, and cheese is sitting on a pair of tens, ordering another drink. None of those hands wins the tournament on its own. Bluffing your way through one pot might look great for a week, but it rarely survives a season.

So accept the cards you’ve been dealt. Read the table, not just your own hand. And know when to call, when to raise and, hardest of all, when to fold.

We’ll stay on the sidelines, with the coffee and the curve. If you want a second pair of eyes on the table, you know where to find us.

GFD, Good trading 🤝